EVICT, NEGLECT, OR INVEST? Community Power and the Politics of Urban Informality Governance in Jakarta
This study analyzes the governance of informal settlements in Jakarta through a comparative analysis of five neighborhoods in North Jakarta, utilizing field observations, interviews, and policy analysis. It examines why state responses to urban informality vary widely, ranging from violent evictions and neglect to collaborative, community-led infrastructure investments.
Why it matters — The research demonstrates that the treatment of informal settlements is not solely dictated by capitalist expansion or colonial legacies, but is actively shaped by community power. It establishes that neighborhoods with stronger organizational capacity, strategic alliances, and political embeddedness can successfully leverage discretionary state authority to secure accommodative policies.
Caveat: The findings are based on a comparative analysis of five specific settlements within a single city, which may limit their direct applicability to different national or political contexts.